Concept preview · by WebCrave · a renovated stegmanns.co.za, not the official website
Stegmanns Incorporated, est. 1890

23 March 2023 · Newsdesk · 4 min read

The impractical hurdle of giving notice to consumers when addresses have changed

Published in MicroFinance South Africa

From a credit provider’s perspective, there exists an unnaturally high hurdle in respect of successfully obtaining default judgment against a consumer who is in default of a credit agreement. How times have changed from the commencement of the National Credit Act back in 2006. One cannot help but look back and evaluate the development of the credit industry with a magnifying glass since then. As responsible stakeholders in the credit industry, we are all in agreement that the equalising of the playing field between consumer and credit provider, has had its benefits to the industry as a whole. However, when one considers the compliance requirements placed before credit providers who merely intend to enforce its rights against consumers who are clearly in default, the actions required appear to be in close comparison to that of a circus.

Although the legislature’s intentions were most certainly pure, and for the benefit of the protection of consumers, the mechanisms placed in the Act have made the process of obtaining judgment by default, a rather strenuous one. As an industry we agree that the purpose of giving ‘proper’ notice to a consumer which may activate certain alternative remedies, but same needs to be weighed against the need to enforce and protect the feasibility of credit providers to continue to
extend credit in a competitive consumers’ market.

One of the essentials contained in a credit agreement, or in fact in any agreement, is the parties’ responsibility to appoint a domicilium citandi et executandi address where each party nominates an address where they are prepared to receive notices, summons or otherwise. In the same breath, it is each party’s responsibility to notify the other party should there be a change in the nominated address. However, the lines become blurred when a party appoints a notice-address, where they do not reside, or as we have seen in practice, an address where no one resides. This begs the question, how does the credit provider ensure that ‘proper’ notice is given and that the defaulting party becomes aware of their defaulting status? The legislature, as well as the precedents of court have placed an unnaturally high hurdle on credit providers to surpass and prove that actual notice was received by the consumer. What makes matters worse, is the fact that not all courts follow the same ‘proper’ notice principle which results in a failed standard of practice and leans more towards a scale of prevalence of possibility.

Although credit providers and attorneys have adopted several mechanisms to track and trace, especially habitual defaulters, our responsibilities are hindered by further legalisation like the Protection of Personal Information Act, as we are no longer able to easily ascertain last known addresses as was previously possible.

Let’s not even discuss the implications (cost and labour wise) if the credit agreement pertains to an immovable property or a vehicle finance agreement where the financed asset, and defaulting party’s notice-address and last known address are in different court jurisdictions.

Although there are judgments that confirm that service on an address chosen by a debtor as the domicilium citandi et executandi, constitutes proper notice[1], the manner of service at a domicilium address, must be effective. It must be such that the process served at the domicilium citandi et executandi would, in the ordinary course, come to the attention of and be received by the intended recipient.[2] Surely this creates a predicament to credit providers in respect of determining a reasonable process to achieve a positive scale of prevalence of notice to a consumer. Where does the boundary lie?

Do we intend to create different processes for proper notice depending on the type of agreement? Or on the type of consumer? Or on the amount involved in possible judgment? Perhaps the solution imamates in the statutory obligation of information service providers to keep personal information updated. Does this negate the consumer’s responsibility to inform the credit provider of his change in notice-address?

Surely if a Sheriff’s responsibility to serve a summons on a Defendant, cannot be negated by giving the summons to a security guard at the notice-address complex[3], then the consumer’s responsibility to inform the credit provider cannot similarly be negated. The consumer needs to accept the consequences of possible judgment by default for his failure to notify a credit provider in writing.

The result of the consumer’s failure, has an adverse effect on his credit record, which would have been the case in the normal course of default in any event. However, the consumer further runs the risk of losing the financed asset involved in his default. All these consequences should be accepted by a consumer once addresses change and credit providers are not properly notified.

By: Carna Labuschagne, Senior Associate

Published 23 March 2023. This article is general information, not legal advice for your situation. Contact us for advice on your matter.